top of page
We make it easy to serve great food. Call the shop or stop by in person to tell use more about your event, your guests, and what you have in mind so we can put together a menu that has your guests asking for seconds from appeteizers to dessert.
Thanksgiving 2025
Let's do this!Fresh Whole Turkey
Fresh, never frozen turkey from Jaindl Farms Pre-cooked & Pre-sliced Turkey
Pre-sliced white meat turkey breast available by the poundHouse Made Turkey Gravy
One quart of our house made turkey gravyBread Stuffing
One pound of house made bread stuffingVegetarian
Mashed Potatoes
Idaho potatoes, sour cream, cream cheese, half & halfVegetarian
Sweet Potato Souffle
Sweet potato, brown sugar, vanillaVegetarian
Cranberry Sauce
One pint of our housemade cranberry sauceVegetarian
Party Platters
Get the party started with some platters built for sophisticated(ish) grazing. Plates optionalAntipasto
Assorted Italian meats, cheeses, and vegetables12"
$45
16"
$75
Tomato & Mozzarella
Vine ripe tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basil, olive oil, salt & pepper12"
$30
16"
$50
Vegetarian
Bruschetta
Vine ripe tomatoes, fresh basil, garlic, bell pepper, red onion, oregano, white balsamic, olive oil, housemade garlic toasts12"
$21
16"
$32
Vegetarian
Filet Mignon Platter (per lb)
Seasoned beef tenderloin or flat iron steak prepared medium rare with horseradish sauce
$40
Flat Iron Platter (per lb)
Seasoned flat iron steak prepared medium rare with horseradish sauce
$23
Assorted Sandwiches
Combination of our Sweet Italian, Breaded Chicken, Grilled Chicken, Roast Beef, Turkey, and Veggie sandwiches18 pieces
$53
24 pieces
$75
Party Trays
Our family's favorite recipes served in party trays with heating instructions, what could be easier?Chicken Marsala
Breaded Bell & Evans chicken cutlet, mushrooms, marsala sauceVeal Marsala
Fully cooked veal cutlets (seasoned bread crumbs, eggs), housemade chicken stock, brown gravy, marsala cooking wine, mushrooms, onions, fresh garlic, flour, fresh parsley, black pepper3 lbs.
$52
4 lbs.
$72
Chicken Romano
Thin sliced Bell & Evans chicken cutlet, lightly coated with romano cheese & flour, white wine lemon sauceChicken Parmigiana
Breaded Bell & Evans chicken cutlet, mozzarella, housemade tomato sauceChicken Piccata
Breaded Bell & Evans chicken cutlet, brown butter caper sauceVeal Parmigiana
Fully cooked veal cutlets (seasoned bread crumbs, eggs), mozzarella, housemade tomato sauce, romano cheese3 lbs
$54
Sausage, Peppers, & Onions
Housemade Italian sausage, bell peppers, onions, housemade tomato sauce3 lbs
$33
4 lbs
$44
Meat Loaf in Gravy
Housemade meat loaf with brown gravy3 lbs
$33
4 lbs
$44
Pork Loin in Gravy
Pepper crusted pork tenderloin with brown gravy3 lbs
$33
4 lbs
$44
Meatballs in Sauce
Housemade meatballs in housemade tomato sauceTurkey Meatballs in Sauce
Housemade turkey meatballs in housemade tomato sauceBuffalo Chicken Meatballs
Ground chicken, panko bread crumbs, cream cheese, carrots, celery, onions, hot sauce, parsley, garlic, salt, pepper36 meatballs
$33
Eggplant Parmigiana
Flour fried eggplant, mozzarella cheese, housemade tomato sauceVegetarian
Eggplant Rollatini
Flour fried eggplant, seasoned ricotta, mozzarella, housemade tomato sauceVegetarian
Lasagna
Lasagna pasta, seasoned ricotta, mozzarella, housemade tomato sauceCheese
$40
Spinach
$40
Meat
$40
Vegetarian
Stuffed Shells
Large shell pasta, seasoned ricotta, mozzarella, housemade tomato sauceVegetarian
Baked Ziti
Penne ziti pasta, seasoned ricotta, mozzarella cheese, housemade tomato sauceVegetarian
Manicotti
Manicotti skin, seasoned ricotta, mozzarella cheese housemade tomato sauce12 count
$30
Vegetarian
Rigatoni Bolognese
Rigatoni pasta with housemade bolognese sauce5 lbs
$38
Cavatelli & Broccoli
Cavatelli pasta, broccoli florets, pecorino romano cheeseVegetarian
Penne Vodka
Penne ziti pasta, housemade vodka cream sauce, pecorino romano cheeseVegetarian
Orecchette, Broccoli Rabe & Sausage
Housemade Italian sausage, broccoli rabe, orecchette pasta, pecorino romano cheese5 lbs
$42
Hot Wings
Bell & Evans chicken wings, hot sauce, black pepperDozen
$7.99
BBQ Wings
Bell & Evans chicken wings, BBQ sauce, black pepperDozen
$7.99
Chicken Tenders
Breaded Bell & Evans chickenper lb
$10.99
Macaroni & Cheese
Cavatappi pasta, white & yellow Vermont cheddar & American cheesesVegetarian
Macaroni & Cheese (5 lbs)
Cavatappi pasta, white & yellow Vermont cheddar & American cheeses
$40
Vegetarian
Mashed Potatoes
Idaho potatoes, sour cream, cream cheese, half & half
$16
Vegetarian
My New Option
3 lbs$16
4.5 lbs$24
Cauliflower Au Gratin
Fresh Cauliflower, Vermont cheddar & American cheeses, bread crumbs, fresh parsley3 lbs
$20
4.5 lbs
$30
Vegetarian
Potatoes Au Gratin
Idaho potatoes, Vermont cheddar & American cheeses, bread crumbs, fresh parsleyVegetarian
Meatloaf and Gravy
Housemade meatloaf with brown gravy
$11.99
Pickup Location
Basking Ridge
Salads & Sides
Your guests could use some roughage.Angie's Mixed Greens
Strawberries, dried cranberries, pignoli nuts, goat cheese, lime vinaigrette
$35
Vegetarian
Classic Caesar
Romaine hearts, housemade garlic croutons, Caesar dressing
$26
Vegetarian
Simple Salad
Mixed greens, cherry tomato, cucumber, bell pepper, onion, oil & vinegar
$26
Vegetarian
Mashed Potatoes
Idaho potatoes, sour cream, cream cheese, half & halfVegetarian
Potatoes Au Gratin
Idaho potatoes, Vermont cheddar & American cheeses, bread crumbs, fresh parsleyVegetarian
Sweet Potato Souffle
Sweet potato, brown sugar, vanilla3 lbs
$18
4 lbs
$24
Vegetarian
Cauliflower Au Gratin
Fresh Cauliflower, Vermont cheddar & American cheeses, bread crumbs, fresh parsley3 lbs
$20
4.5 lbs
$30
Vegetarian
Broccoli Florets
Blended oil, fresh garlic, salt, black & cracked red pepper
$5.99
Vegetarian
Glazed Carrots
Baby carrots, honey, salt & black pepper
$4.99
Vegetarian
Broccoli Rabe
Housemade chicken stock, fresh garlic, vegetable oil, salt, black pepper, crushed red pepper
$8.99
Sauteed Spinach
Housemade chicken stock, fresh garlic & shallot, vegetable oil, salt, black pepper, crushed red pepper
$7.99
Breads
Fresh bread baked dailyFrench Baguette
$3
Vegetarian
Pickup Location
Basking Ridge
Semolina Bread
$3
Vegetarian
Italian Bastone
$3
Vegetarian
Pickup Location
Basking Ridge
Dinner Rolls
$0.50
Vegetarian
Housemade Brioche
$0.60
Vegetarian
Housemade Garlic Bread (made with French bread)
Chopped garlic, butter, oregano, parsley, romano cheese
$3
Vegetarian
Pickup Location
Basking Ridge
Housemade Garlic Bread (made with Italian Bread)
Chopped garlic, butter, oregano, parsley, romano cheese
$5
Vegetarian
Pickup Location
Basking Ridge
Desserts
"Leave the gun, take the cannoli." -Peter ClemenzaMini Cannolis
Plain shell, chocolate chip cream fillingPlain (each)
$1.25
Chocolate dipped (each)
$1.50
Vegetarian
Sfogliatella
Lemon & orange zest, ricotta cheese, puff pastryEach
$2
Vegetarian
Dessert Platter
Assortment of cannolis, cookies, & sfogliatella
$40
Vegetarian
Housemade Carrot Cake
Carrot, walnut, raisins, cream cheese frosting (8-10 slices)Small
$28
Large
$35
Vegetarian
Housemade Cheesecake
Sour cream, cream cheese, cherry compote (8-10 slices)Small
$28
Large
$35
Vegetarian
Chocolate Chip Cookies
Our famous housemade chocolate chip cookiesPlain
$4.99
Chocolate Dipped
$5.99
Vegetarian
bottom of page